A minute for your feedback please

Saturday, June 30, 2012

Why management can never be a profession-no PHOSITA or public duty

Under patent law, PHOSITA(person having ordinary skill and training in the art) is a fictional person, considered to have the normal skills and knowledge in a particular technical field, without being a genius. For a patent to be considered non obvious, having an inventive step and application having full disclosure, the standard is applied whether it was obvious to and comprehendible by a PHOSITA. By defining this mythical concept/construct of John Doe(the exact details are only filled in on case-case basis), courts make it easier to award of reject patents.

Professions like accountancy, law, medicine all have CBOK(Common body of knowledge), Code of Conduct, professional standards and continuing professional education(CPE).In contrast, management has the following gaps in this idea of profession
  1. Absence of requisite skill-for example not being aware of relevant amendments, statutory laws, latest research in management field etc. I agree that not even CPE is enough for ensuring updation, but atleast it is something. Management does not even have that. 
  2. No ethical standards:-Though I personally feel that professional ethics standards are more of locking the stable after the horse has bolted, or limiting competition, atleast it does make the public aware of what minimum to expect from their professionals, and gives them liberty to sue for malpractice/breach of trust if not met. Again, this need to adhere to a code of ethics is not imposed by the organization but is usually employer specific. 
  3. No prescribed training:-Though some may debate the relative merits of apprenticeship versus on the full tome job training(say ICAEW vs CIMA models), some structured guild like training is helpful to learn a profession. Validity of this is not yet proven for management, so while it may be superior to any profession, it cannot be classed as one.
  4. No explicit fiduciary relationship:-Code of ethics etc exists in part due to the fiduiciary relationship between professional and client, which is nebulous when it comes to the relationship between a manager, business entity and its owners! 
So the next time people liken management to a professional, excuse me for differing! 

1 comment:

  1. Hi,

    You have given very nice post it is very knowledgable and result oriented.

    Educaton is key of success in life.

    We are Now HCL the real IT giant offers Limited seats for Industrial Project Training & Internship in New Delhi.
    The live Project Training module of our course can make a huge difference to your profile and career prospects. So don't settle for the second-best. Choose WINNERS i.e. HCL
    Summer Training Delhi , Project Training Delhi , HCL Training Centre Delhi ,
    On successful completion of Project Training, HCL will issue Certificate of Completion
    The candidates who are eligible and selected for Project Training would be undergoing this training in HCL Career Development Centre, Preet Vihar , NEW DELHI
    SEATS WOULD HAVE TO BE BOOKED NOW
    For 45 Days, 8 weeks, 2 months, 6 months and 6 Weeks Project training for Btech, MCA, BCA, BSc IT, M.Sc IT, Polytechnic, etc

    ReplyDelete